ABSTRACT
Abstract Paul Bouts (1900-1999) was a Belgian pedagogue, a Roman Catholic priest, and the founder of Psychognomy, which is a personality diagnostic system combining phrenology and several related practices - typology, craniofacial measurements, physiognomy, graphology etc. Bouts had a fragile health; therefore, it is unlikely that he travelled to Brazil. Despite this, his most famous book, rich in conservative and religious thoughts, was translated to Portuguese and published with ecclesiastic support in 1943, and the doctrine acquired good reputation among Brazilian members of the clergy, politicians, teachers, and military personnel. Lay scholars and medical doctors founded a Brazilian institute devoted to the study and diffusion of psychognomy in 1949. They published two volumes of a psychognomy treatise, and the institute was active until the early 1960s, when social interest in the subject rapidly vanished.
Resumo Paul Bouts (1900-1999) foi um pedagogo e padre católico belga que criou a psicognomia, um sistema de análise caracterológica que combinava elementos da frenologia, tipologia, medições craniofaciais, fisionomia, grafologia etc. Suas teorias influenciaram acadêmicos, religiosos, políticos e militares brasileiros. Bouts tinha uma saúde frágil, e não há evidências de que tenha estado no Brasil. Seu livro mais famoso, Psicognomia, foi publicado no país em 1943 com aval da censura eclesiástica e com apêndices especiais. A doutrina levou, ainda, à criação, em 1949, de um instituto privado de divulgação e estudos de psicognomia com sede no Rio de Janeiro, que publicou dois volumes de um tratado sobre o tema e permaneceu ativo até o início da década de 1960, quando o interesse pelo assunto rapidamente desapareceu na sociedade.
ABSTRACT
Resumen En medio de la Guerra Civil ocurrida en Chile el año 1891, apareció publicado en el periódico brasileño Diário de Campinas el artículo titulado "Balmaceda", de autoría de Joaquim Nogueira de Sá Itagiba, donde analiza el delirio del político chileno José Manuel Balmaceda, presidente de la República entre 1886 y 1891, explicando su comportamiento, definido como el característico del dictador y el tirano. El artículo es pródigo en la utilización de diversas teorías alienistas que intentan identificar al sujeto criminal, respondiendo a los ideales de normalización social. El artículo forma parte del libro La prensa extranjera y la dictadura chilena, de Alberto Fagalde, publicado en 1891, en Chile.
Abstract In the midst of the Civil War in Chile in 1891, the Brazilian newspaper Diário de Campinas published an article entitled "Balmaceda," by Joaquim Nogueira de Sá Itagiba, which analyzes the delirium of Chilean politician José Manuel Balmaceda, president of the Republic from 1886 to 1891 in order to explain his behavior, which it defines as characteristic of a dictator and a tyrant. The article makes liberal use of various psychiatric theories that sought to identify the criminal subject in response to ideals of social normalization. The article was part of the book La prensa extranjera y la dictadura chilena, by Alberto Fagalde, published in 1891, in Chile.
Subject(s)
Humans , Male , History, 19th Century , Politics , Psychological Theory , Delirium/history , Famous Persons , Newspapers as Topic/history , Phrenology/history , Psychiatry/history , ChileABSTRACT
ABSTRACT Belgian colonizers used phrenology to create an irreducible division between the two major groups living for centuries in Rwanda-Urundi. This formed the basis for the implementation of systematic efforts to subdue the large Hutu population. Both the Hutus and the smaller, and initially privileged, Tutsi group soon incorporated the racist discourse, which was pivotal to the gradual increase in violence before and after Rwandan independence in 1962. The Rwandan genocide in 1994 culminated in the horrible pinnacle of this process, involving recurrent episodes of slaughtering. Doctors should not underestimate the racist potential of pseudoscientific misconceptions.
RESUMO Os colonizadores belgas usaram a frenologia para criar uma divisão irredutível entre os dois maiores grupos populacionais vivendo há séculos em Ruanda-Urundi. Isso criou as bases para a implementação de esforços sistemáticos para subjugar a grande população Hutu. Tanto os Hutu quanto o grupo menor e inicialmente privilegiado dos Tutsi logo incorporaram o discurso racista, que foi crucial no aumento gradual da violência antes e após a independência de Ruanda em 1962. O genocídio de 1994 constituiu o terrível ápice deste processo envolvendo massacres repetidos. Os médicos não devem subestimar o potencial racista e discriminatório de falsas concepções pseudocientíficas.
Subject(s)
Humans , History, 17th Century , History, 18th Century , History, 19th Century , History, 20th Century , Phrenology/history , Genocide/history , Rwanda , Violence , Racism/historyABSTRACT
Resumen El presente artículo hace una breve revisión histórica de la frenología, o doctrina del cerebro, que fue creada por Franz Joseph Gall y desarrollada por Johan Caspar Spurzheim y George Combe. La frenología se difundió por diversos países como Francia e Inglaterra, pero fue en Estados Unidos, donde alcanzó un alto nivel de difusión a través de la fundación de sociedades frenológicas y revistas. Además, aunque sus postulados fueron equivocados, es un antecedente importante del localizacionanismo y de la psicología aplicada, que significó el paso de las explicaciones metafísicas a la búsqueda de los fundamentos neurofisiológicos de la conducta humana. En tal sentido, la frenología tiene un lugar bien ganado en la historia de la psicología y de las neurociencias en general, que merece ser reconocido con el valor que le corresponde.
This article makes a brief historical review of the phrenology, or doctrine of the brain, which was created by Franz Joseph Gall and developed by Johan Caspar Spurzheim and George Combe. Phrenology was spread by various countries like France and England, but it was in the United States, where it reached a high level of diffusion through the foundation of phrenological societies and journal. Moreover, although their postulates were wrong, it is an important antecedent of applied psychology, which meant the passage of metaphysical explanations to the search of the neurophysiological foundations of human behavior. In that sense, phrenology has a well-earned place in the history of psychology and neuroscience in general, which deserves to be recognized with the value that corresponds to it.
Subject(s)
Humans , Phrenology , Psychology, Applied , Behavior , Cerebrum , NeurophysiologyABSTRACT
Phineas Gage es a no dudar, uno de los pacientes más famosos de la historia de la neurología, una cita indefectible en textos neurológicos y objeto de numerosos artículos científicos a lo largo de más de ciento cincuenta años. Este caso tan excepcional ha permitido establecer el papel principal que en el pensamiento y en la capacidad de sociabilizar tienen las regiones frontales del cerebro, especialmente la porción ventromedial, así como los circuitos y sistemas relacionados con las emociones, cuya activación conjunta con las regiones frontales, participa de forma fundamental en la planificación y toma de decisiones, y contribuye a determinar el tono afectivo de nuestras relaciones sociales. Una revisión sumaria de la historia de la medicina nos indica que es inusual que el nombre de un paciente y no el del médico que describe una situación clínica, sea mencionado para la posteridad. ¿Por qué entonces se recuerda el nombre de Gage y no el de su médico tratante y acusioso descriptor de su insania, John Martyn Harlow? Quizá porque el caso es todavía considerado como una de las mejores descripciones de un desorden "psicopático" del comportamiento relacionado con una lesión traumática del córtex prefrontal, donde la correlación anatomoclínica ha sido intentada empleando diversas concepciones y métodos a la usanza de los diversos momentos históricos. La ocasión de este relato permitirá al lector pasearse a través de la fascinante evolución y perfeccionamiento de las ideas que han llevado al conocimiento actual de la localización de las funciones neurológicas, y a atisbar el desentrañamiento de los loci de la mente y del espíritu
Phineas Gage is doubtless one of the most famous patients in the history of neurology. An infallible quote in neurology textbooks and the object of numerous scientific articles for over one hundred and fifty years. This exceptional case has allowed investigators to establish the role of the frontal cortex, specifically its ventromedial portion in the development of human thought and his/her capacity to socialize and also the close relationship of these structures with emotion-related circuits and systems which participate in the decision-making process and contributes to determine the affective tone of social interaction. A brief glance at the history of medicine shows it is exceedingly infrequent for a patient's name to transcend into posterity. Why then is the name Gage remembered instead of John Martin Harlow's, the keen describer of Gage's insanity? Perhaps because Gage's case is still considered one of the salient descriptions of a "psychopathic" disorder of behavior directly related to a traumatic lesion of the prefrontal cortex in which an anatomoclinical correlation has been attempted through diverse conceptions and methods tailored to each historical period of time. Gage's tale will take the reader for a ride along the fascinating evolutional pathways of medical thinking that have permitted the acquisition of knowledgeable localization of neurological function and allowed scientists to peep into the entangled realm of the mind and spirit